The Messianic Way


The Truth About Matrilineal Descent – InterfaithFamily

A case for patrilineal descent within Judaism.

The orthodox dividing line.

The Truth About Matrilineal Descent – InterfaithFamily.

March 22, 2007

A mamzer who is a scholar takes precedence over a High Priest who is an ignoramus. — Babylonian Talmud, Horayot 13a

Since I became involved in Jewish life about seven years ago, I have had the pleasure of meeting a number of Jews who, like me, are the children of a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother. Aside from the feelings of anger and alienation caused by our inequitable treatment within the Jewish community — treatment that many Jews with two Jewish parents fail to notice — the problems we experience goes far beyond being denied ritual honors or formal membership in an Orthodox or Conservative synagogue.

What I have most often noticed in other “patrilineal” Jews is a profound perplexity at our exclusion. Why, we often wonder, are segments of the Jewish community compelled to treat children of intermarriage in such an insensitive, cookie-cutter way — deciding that whether we are considered part of the Jewish family depends on the arbitrary fact of our being the fruit of Jewish sperm or a Jewish egg?

Having majored in religion in college, I have had the opportunity to examine the sources of matrilineal descent in Judaism in a way that few other patrilineal Jews have. In the hopes of lessening the confusion many patrilineal Jews feel about their situation, and of helping us all to achieve some measure of justice from the organized Jewish community, I want to give all patrilineal Jews the facts — scriptural, halakhic (Jewish legal), and sociological — they need to counter the arguments for our exclusion. When we come to those who would exclude us with the real facts in hand, I firmly believe, the wider Jewish community will be forced to admit that there is not a single argument given for reckoning Jewish descent matrilineally that can withstand the heat of serious scrutiny.

While it is impossible to treat this topic fully within the limits of a short article, I hope that what I can provide will prompt others who have been wrongfully denied their birthright to investigate the sources further and thereby be able to challenge this entrenched form of discrimination within Judaism.

The most commonly given rationales for matrilineal descent are:

  1. an interpretation of Deuteronomy 7:3-4, later encoded in the Mishnah (a compendium of oral interpretations of the Torah), and the expulsion of the foreign wives in the book of Ezra
  2. the certainty of maternity, versus the uncertainty of paternity
  3. supposed rabbinic humanitarian concern for Jewish women who had been raped, and their children
  4. the “need” of the community to punish men who have intermarried
  5. the inalienable nature of the Jewish covenant with God.

As I will show, all of these rationales are inadequate, and some are ethically dubious.


About Shimshon

Humility is the beginning of ones relationship with God, or the reminder of it's existence...... LOVE ~ Life's Only Valuable Emotion

2 comments on “The Truth About Matrilineal Descent – InterfaithFamily

  1. cfryalls
    January 14, 2015

    This seems to fit in with your post here David.


    • Shimshon
      January 14, 2015

      You’re right! I drafted this post the same day and then forgot about it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on January 13, 2015 by in Shimshon's Blog, The Messianic Way Blog and tagged , , .
Morning Meditations

"When you awake in the morning, learn something to inspire you and mediate upon it, then plunge forward full of light with which to illuminate the darkness." -Rabbi Tzvi Freeman

Jewish adventures in the diaspora.

Reb Rez

Scripture, ethics and spiritual formation

%d bloggers like this: